Arguable vs Defensible: When To Use Each One In Writing?

When it comes to making a point, choosing the right words can make all the difference. In particular, the words “arguable” and “defensible” are often used interchangeably, but they have distinct meanings that can impact the strength of your argument. So which word should you use, and what do they mean?

The proper word to use depends on the context of your argument. Both “arguable” and “defensible” are valid words to use, but they have different connotations. “Arguable” means that something is open to debate or dispute, while “defensible” means that something can be justified or supported with evidence.

For example, if you say that “the sky is blue,” that statement is not arguable because it is a fact that can be easily proven. However, if you say that “the best color is blue,” that statement is arguable because it is a matter of opinion that can be debated. On the other hand, if you say that “the sky is blue because of the way light is scattered in the atmosphere,” that statement is defensible because it is supported by scientific evidence.

In this article, we will explore the differences between these two words and how to use them effectively in your writing. By understanding the nuances of these words, you can strengthen your arguments and make a more persuasive case for your point of view.

Define Arguable

Arguable is a term used to describe something that is open to debate or dispute. It is a statement or position that can be challenged or questioned, and may not have a clear or definitive answer. In other words, it is a matter of opinion or interpretation, rather than fact.

For example, the statement “coffee is the best beverage” is arguable because some people may prefer tea or soda instead. Similarly, the statement “dogs are better pets than cats” is also arguable because some people may prefer the independence and low-maintenance of cats over the loyalty and affection of dogs.

Define Defensible

Defensible, on the other hand, is a term used to describe something that can be justified or supported with evidence or reasoning. It is a statement or position that can be defended against criticism or opposition. In other words, it is a matter of fact or logic, rather than opinion.

For example, the statement “water is essential for human survival” is defensible because it is supported by scientific evidence and common knowledge. Similarly, the statement “the earth revolves around the sun” is also defensible because it is based on observable phenomena and mathematical calculations.

Comparison of Arguable and Defensible Statements

Arguable	Defensible
Cats are better pets than dogs.	Dogs are more loyal and affectionate than cats.
Pineapple belongs on pizza.	Pineapple is a common topping for pizza in some regions and cultures.
Vaccines cause autism.	Scientific studies have shown no causal link between vaccines and autism.

How To Properly Use The Words In A Sentence

Proper usage of words in a sentence is crucial in effective communication. Choosing the right words is essential in conveying the intended message and avoiding confusion. In this section, we will discuss the proper usage of the words arguable and defensible.

How To Use Arguable In A Sentence

The word arguable is an adjective that means capable of being argued or disputed. It is often used to express a point that is open to debate or discussion. Here are some examples of how to use arguable in a sentence:

• It is arguable whether or not technology has improved our quality of life.
• The decision to invest in that company is arguable.
• Her statement is arguable because there is no concrete evidence to support it.

As you can see, the word arguable is often used to express opinions or beliefs that are not necessarily supported by facts. It is important to note that using arguable in a sentence does not necessarily mean that the argument is weak or invalid. It simply means that there is room for discussion or debate.

How To Use Defensible In A Sentence

The word defensible is an adjective that means able to be defended or justified. It is often used to express a point that is supported by evidence or reasoning. Here are some examples of how to use defensible in a sentence:

• The decision to increase taxes is defensible because it will provide funding for important public services.
• His argument is defensible because he has provided solid evidence to support his claims.
• Her actions are defensible because she was acting in self-defense.

As you can see, the word defensible is often used to express opinions or beliefs that are supported by facts or evidence. Using defensible in a sentence indicates that the argument is strong and valid.

More Examples Of Arguable & Defensible Used In Sentences

In order to better understand the differences between arguable and defensible, it is important to see how they are used in sentences. Here are some examples:

Examples Of Using Arguable In A Sentence

• It is arguable whether or not the new policy will be effective.
• His claim that he is the best candidate for the job is highly arguable.
• The decision to cancel the event is arguable given the current circumstances.
• There is an arguable case for reducing taxes on small businesses.
• The argument that video games cause violence is highly arguable.
• It is arguable that the company’s profits have been affected by the recent economic downturn.
• There is an arguable connection between climate change and the increase in natural disasters.
• The idea that social media is addictive is an arguable one.
• It is arguable whether or not the government’s new healthcare plan will benefit the majority of citizens.
• The claim that organic food is better for you is highly arguable.

Examples Of Using Defensible In A Sentence

• The company’s decision to expand into new markets is defensible given their current success.
• Her argument that the company should invest in renewable energy is highly defensible.
• The decision to terminate the employee was defensible due to their repeated violations of company policy.
• It is defensible to argue that education is the key to reducing poverty.
• The claim that exercise is good for your health is highly defensible.
• It is defensible to say that the company’s profits have been affected by the recent economic downturn.
• The decision to increase funding for public schools is defensible given the need for better education.
• His argument that the government should invest in infrastructure is highly defensible.
• The idea that technology has improved our lives is a defensible one.
• It is defensible to argue that the company’s new product will be successful in the market.

Common Mistakes To Avoid

While the terms arguable and defensible may seem interchangeable, using them interchangeably can lead to confusion and miscommunication. Here are some common mistakes to avoid:

Using “Arguable” When You Mean “Defensible”

One common mistake is using “arguable” when you actually mean “defensible.” While both terms imply that a position can be supported with evidence and reasoning, “arguable” suggests that there may be room for debate or disagreement, while “defensible” implies that the position is well-supported and can withstand scrutiny.

For example, if someone says, “The benefits of exercise are arguable,” they are suggesting that there is significant disagreement or uncertainty about whether exercise is beneficial. However, if they say, “The benefits of exercise are defensible,” they are suggesting that there is strong evidence to support the claim that exercise is beneficial.

Using “Defensible” When You Mean “Arguable”

Another common mistake is using “defensible” when you actually mean “arguable.” While both terms suggest that a position can be supported with evidence and reasoning, “arguable” implies that there may be room for debate or disagreement, while “defensible” implies that the position is well-supported and can withstand scrutiny.

For example, if someone says, “The existence of aliens is defensible,” they are suggesting that there is strong evidence to support the claim that aliens exist. However, if they say, “The existence of aliens is arguable,” they are suggesting that there is room for debate or disagreement about whether aliens exist.

Tips To Avoid These Mistakes

• Be clear about what you mean when using these terms
• Consider the connotations of each term before using them
• Use examples to clarify your meaning
• Proofread your writing to ensure that you are using the correct term

Context Matters

When it comes to choosing between the words “arguable” and “defensible,” context is key. The choice between these two words can depend on the situation in which they are used and the message that is being conveyed.

Examples Of Different Contexts

Let’s take a look at some examples of different contexts and how the choice between “arguable” and “defensible” might change:

• Legal Context: In a legal context, the word “defensible” is often used to describe a position or argument that is able to be supported with evidence and reasoning. On the other hand, the word “arguable” might be used to describe a position that is open to debate or interpretation. For example, a lawyer might argue that their client’s actions were defensible in court, meaning that they had a valid reason for their behavior that can be supported with evidence.
• Academic Context: In an academic context, the choice between “arguable” and “defensible” might depend on the type of writing or research being done. For example, in a research paper, a writer might use the word “defensible” to describe a hypothesis or argument that is supported by data and research. However, in a persuasive essay, the word “arguable” might be used to describe a position that is open to debate or discussion.
• Business Context: In a business context, the choice between “arguable” and “defensible” might depend on the message that is being conveyed. For example, a company might use the word “defensible” to describe a decision or action that is supported by data and analysis. On the other hand, the word “arguable” might be used to describe a position that is open to debate or disagreement.

Overall, the choice between “arguable” and “defensible” depends on the context in which they are used and the message that is being conveyed. By understanding the nuances of these words, writers can choose the right word to accurately convey their message and strengthen their writing.

Exceptions To The Rules

While the rules for using arguable and defensible are generally straightforward, there are some exceptions where they might not apply. In these cases, it is important to understand the nuances of the language and the context in which the words are being used.

Exceptions For Arguable

Arguable is typically used to describe a point or argument that is open to debate or interpretation. However, there are some exceptions where arguable might not be the best choice:

• Factual statements: When making a statement of fact, it is not appropriate to use arguable. In this case, defensible would be a better choice. For example, “The sky is blue” is defensible, while “The sky is arguable” does not make sense.
• Expert opinions: When citing an expert opinion, it is important to use language that conveys their authority and expertise. In this case, defensible would be a better choice. For example, “The expert’s opinion is defensible” carries more weight than “The expert’s opinion is arguable.”

Exceptions For Defensible

Defensible is typically used to describe a point or argument that is supported by evidence or reasoning. However, there are some exceptions where defensible might not be the best choice:

• Moral or ethical issues: When discussing moral or ethical issues, it is important to use language that conveys the complexity and subjectivity of the topic. In this case, arguable would be a better choice. For example, “The morality of capital punishment is arguable” acknowledges the different perspectives on the issue.
• Creative works: When discussing creative works like literature or art, it is important to use language that conveys the subjective nature of the work. In this case, arguable would be a better choice. For example, “The meaning of the poem is arguable” acknowledges that different readers may interpret the poem differently.

Practice Exercises

Now that we have a better understanding of the differences between arguable and defensible, it’s time to put that knowledge into practice. Here are some exercises that will help you improve your understanding and use of these terms in sentences:

Exercise 1:

Read the following sentences and determine if they are arguable or defensible. Write your answer in the space provided.

Sentence	Arguable or Defensible?
The Earth is flat.	Arguable
The Earth revolves around the sun.	Defensible
Cats are better than dogs.	Arguable
The sky is blue.	Defensible

Exercise 2:

Write a sentence using arguable and another using defensible. Then, switch sentences with a partner and determine if their sentence is arguable or defensible.

Exercise 3:

Read the following paragraph and identify all of the arguable and defensible statements. Write your answers in the space provided.

“The death penalty is a necessary form of punishment for heinous crimes. While some argue that it is inhumane and ineffective, the fact remains that it serves as a deterrent and ensures justice for victims and their families. However, there is room for improvement in the way the death penalty is carried out, such as ensuring that the defendant is given a fair trial and that the execution is carried out humanely.”

Statement	Arguable or Defensible?
The death penalty is a necessary form of punishment for heinous crimes.	Defensible
While some argue that it is inhumane and ineffective, the fact remains that it serves as a deterrent and ensures justice for victims and their families.	Arguable
There is room for improvement in the way the death penalty is carried out, such as ensuring that the defendant is given a fair trial and that the execution is carried out humanely.	Defensible

These exercises should help you improve your understanding and use of arguable and defensible in sentences. If you have any questions or need further clarification, don’t hesitate to ask.

Conclusion

After exploring the differences between arguable and defensible language use, it is clear that the latter is the more effective choice for clear and persuasive communication. By using defensible language, writers can present their arguments in a way that is supported by evidence and logical reasoning, rather than relying on subjective opinions or emotional appeals.

Some key takeaways from this article include:

• Arguable language can weaken the strength of an argument and make it less convincing.
• Defensible language is supported by evidence and logical reasoning, making it a more effective choice for persuasive communication.
• Using defensible language requires careful attention to word choice and avoiding subjective opinions or emotional appeals.

While mastering grammar and language use may seem daunting, it is an essential skill for anyone who wants to communicate effectively and persuasively. By continuing to learn and practice, readers can improve their writing and make a greater impact with their words.